Gender identity

Pomogender

A gender that's definitely there and won't go into words — not for lack of trying, but because none of the available words are the right shape.

Category
Exploring
Pronouns
Any set
Read
6 min

Overview

What pomogender means.

Pomogender is short for postmodern gender. It names a gender that can't be described, sorted or fitted into the categories that exist — including the newer ones people offer you as a kindness.

Read this part first. This is a small word. It appeared online in the mid-2010s and it lives on wiki pages and a scattering of forum threads. There are no memoirs behind it, no research, no elders, no settled definition.

The people using it don't agree either. Some mean "my gender is undefinable". Others mean "I reject the whole system of gender categories". Those are different claims wearing the same word.

So this page is shorter than most on this site, and it's built differently. What follows describes the experience of having a gender you can't name — which a great many people report — rather than a pomogender culture, because there isn't one to report on. Where we don't know, we say so.

The core of it is a specific kind of failure. You try the words on. Man. Woman. Nonbinary. Agender. Genderfluid. Each is close enough that you understand why someone handed it to you. None of them is it.

Not "none of them fits yet". Not "I haven't found mine". The shape is wrong at the level of shape.

And it isn't emptiness. There's something there. It has weight, it reacts, it objects when people get it wrong. It just doesn't come apart into pieces that have names.

Rejecting or deconstructing the concept of gender labels altogether. A postmodern approach to gender.

Pomogender in one line

Origin

Where the word comes from

The word first appeared in 2013 in a post on the Asexual Visibility and Education Network (AVEN) forums, built by analogy with pomosexual — an older term for a sexual orientation that resists fixed labels. "Pomo" is short for postmodern: since the 1990s, postmodern gender theory has treated gender as something spoken into being through language and repetition, rather than a fixed inner fact, and pomogender borrows that framing to describe a gender that current words can't capture.

It spread afterwards through gender wikis and Tumblr rather than through any organisation or writer, and it has stayed small and loosely defined ever since. Unlike genderpunk or gender nihilism, it isn't necessarily a political rejection of gender as a system — some people mean exactly that, but others simply mean their own gender doesn't fit any existing word, including the newer ones.

Signs people describe

Common experiences

None of these is a test. Most people recognise a few and shrug at the rest.

01

Someone asks what you are and you have a genuine answer in your head.

The sentence for it does not exist.

02

You have read the microlabel lists.

All of them, more than once. Nothing landed, and it wasn't for want of trying.

03

You say "nonbinary" out loud because it's the closest almost-true thing and it ends the conversation. Then you walk away feeling faintly dishonest.

04

"Do you feel more like a man or a woman" doesn't land as invasive so much as badly built — like being asked which day of the week is heaviest.

05

You suspect the filing system is the problem rather than you, and you can't decide whether that's an insight or just arrogance.

06

Gender explanations that resolve neatly irritate you, including good ones, including ones by people you like.

07

Gender fields on forms: none of the options is exactly a lie, and none of them is true.

08

You've seriously considered that you're making this up.

Regularly. Usually late at night.

09

When somebody gets it wrong, you know instantly — even though you couldn't have told them in advance what getting it right would have looked like.

Day to day

What it looks like on a normal Tuesday

Nothing about the day is dramatic. That is rather the point.

You get dressed. Mostly you dress so that nobody reads you as anything in particular, which takes effort even when it looks like not trying.

Coffee. "Thanks, mate." Or "thanks, love." You don't correct it, because correcting it means offering a replacement, and you don't have one to hand over.

A form at the dentist. Male, Female, Other. You tick Other. You feel nothing much about it. Other is at least honest about being the leftover box.

Group chat. Someone's been trying new pronouns and asks what you landed on. You type a sentence. Delete it. Send "still figuring it out", which isn't quite a lie and isn't the truth.

Someone at work talks for ten minutes about how they finally found their word and how much lighter they feel. You're glad for them. There's a small ache underneath it you don't mention.

Evening. Nobody asked you anything difficult. You still spent a low, steady amount of energy standing slightly outside the sentence everyone else was in.

It doesn't ruin the day. It also doesn't go anywhere.

Across the parts of a life

Open the area you came here for.

Straight answers

What people get wrong

It's just nonbinary with extra steps.

Nonbinary gives you a position — not a man, not a woman. This says the map itself fails, including the part of the map that nonbinary sits on. Plenty of people use both words: one for accuracy, one for getting through the day.

If you can't define it, you haven't looked hard enough.

Most people who reach for this word arrive after years of looking. They've read the lists. They tried the ones that nearly worked. Not finding a word after a long search is a result, not a gap in the search.

You just read some theory and got clever about it.

The name is borrowed from academia. The people using it mostly haven't read a word of Butler or Foucault and don't need to have. You don't need a reading list to notice the boxes don't hold you.

Undefinable means it doesn't matter.

Unnameable and unimportant are not the same thing. You can't say what it is and still know instantly when someone gets it wrong. That reaction is the evidence.

It means you think gender is fake or you reject gender for everyone.

Some people who use this word do mean that, and this is exactly where the community splits. Most just mean their own. Making it a claim about other people's genders is a choice, not a definition, and you're not required to make it.

Take care

On the hard days

The hard part is not the not-knowing. It's that you can't hand it to anyone.

Everyone else in the queer group has a noun. They say theirs, people nod, the conversation moves on. You say yours and the conversation stops for a tutorial you didn't want to give.

So you get quiet in the rooms that were meant to be the easy rooms. That's a particular kind of lonely, and it catches people off guard.

Then there's the fraud feeling. Not "am I queer enough" — the older, colder version. Maybe there's nothing here. Maybe I built a word around an absence and got attached to it.

That thought turns up most at night and it argues well. It's worth knowing that it turns up for nearly everyone without a clean label, including people who are certain by daylight.

Other people's reading of you doesn't help. Undefined gets heard as undecided. You get treated as mid-process by people waiting politely for you to finish.

What helps, in the order people report it helping. One person who takes the incomplete answer without flinching. Describing what you want done rather than what you are. Giving yourself permission to stop searching without calling the search a failure.

And a plain note. If the not-knowing sits under a heaviness that doesn't lift, or you're finding it hard to see a reason to keep going, that's worth telling someone out loud — a friend, a doctor, a helpline. That's not about gender. It's about you still being here.

Pronouns

Pronouns

There's no pattern here. People who use this word use every set going — she, he, they, neopronouns, several at once, or none in particular.

Some rotate on purpose, so that no single one settles into a description. Some ask for "any", which is not indifference but a refusal to be pinned by grammar.

And plenty keep the pronouns they were raised with, because arguing costs more than it's worth, or because it isn't safe. Your pronouns are a tool for other people to use. They don't have to be a summary of you.

All pronoun sets →

Consider another path

This might not be your word if…

  • 1You haven't actually tried the existing words yet. Try them. They're free, and one of them fitting is much easier than this.
  • 2The honest answer to "what's there" is nothing. That's agender, and it will get you further with far less explaining.
  • 3You can define it perfectly well — you're just tired of explaining it to people who don't deserve the explanation. That's privacy, not undefinability. Different thing, and completely reasonable.
  • 4What you mean is that you don't care about gender. That's apathy about the question, not an unnameable answer to it. Gender apathetic or cassgender says it better.
  • 5You're three weeks into questioning and this feels like somewhere to sit down. It might be. It might also be a stall. Gender questioning is the honest word while you're still moving.
  • 6Your point is mainly political — that categories are a con and you won't play. Genderqueer says that, people understand it, and it comes with actual history.
  • 7You're a man or a woman who doesn't perform it the way you're told to. That's the rules being narrow, not your gender being unnameable. Plenty of men and women live nothing like the instructions.
  • 8You like the word more than you recognise yourself in it. If the appeal is that it sounds interesting, put it down and check again in a month.

Questions people ask

Frequently asked questions

Is pomogender a real identity or just a Tumblr word?+

Both, honestly. It was coined online in the mid-2010s and it lives on wikis and forums rather than in research or memoirs. Being coined online doesn't make an experience fake — plenty of words we now use started that way. But it doesn't make the word useful either. The only test that matters is whether the description above matches something you already had before you read it. If you had to talk yourself into it, it probably isn't yours.

What's the difference between pomogender, nonbinary and agender?+

Nonbinary tells you a position: not a man, not a woman. Agender tells you there's nothing there. Pomogender says something is there, it has weight, and no available category — including those two — describes it. In practice many people who use this word also call themselves nonbinary in public, because it's understood. If your honest answer to "what's there" is "nothing", agender is the more accurate word and it will serve you better.

Is there a pomogender flag?+

There are images circulating that people call one, but the versions disagree with each other and none has a clear, documented origin. We'd rather show you nothing than show you the wrong colours. If your corner of the internet uses a particular one, use that. Nothing about this requires a flag to be true.

How do I tell people if I can't explain it?+

Stop trying to define it and describe the effects instead. "Man and woman both feel like the wrong file. I don't have a better word yet. Use they, or use anything, and don't call me your daughter." That's a complete request even though it isn't a complete definition. Most people want to know what to do, not what you are. And you can borrow a nearby word — nonbinary, queer — for public use without it being a lie.

The flag

Designer uncertain — lgbtqia.wiki says the flag 'may have been' made by beyond-mogai-pride-flags on 2017-08-15, while the fetched post is dated 2017-08-05; record image is a JPEG.

Sources

Still figuring things out?

Twenty questions, four minutes, and a few words worth trying on.